Current:Home > MyJudge who nixed Musk’s pay package hears arguments on massive fee request from plaintiff lawyers-InfoLens
Judge who nixed Musk’s pay package hears arguments on massive fee request from plaintiff lawyers
View Date:2024-12-23 14:59:23
WILMINGTON, Del. (AP) — A Delaware judge heard arguments Monday over a massive and unprecedented fee request by lawyers who successfully argued that a massive and unprecedented pay package for Tesla CEO Elon Musk was illegal and should be voided.
Attorneys for a Tesla stockholder who challenged Musk’s 2018 compensation package are asking Chancellor Kathaleen St. Jude McCormick to award them legal fees in the form of stock in the electric vehicle company valued at more than $7 billion at current trading prices. The 2018 compensation package for Musk that was rescinded by the judge was potentially worth more than $55 billion.
After a full day of expert-witness testimony and arguments by attorneys, McCormick gave no indication on when she would rule on the fee request.
The fee amount sought by plaintiffs’ attorneys dwarfs the current record $688 million in legal fees awarded in 2008 in litigation stemming from the collapse of Enron.
Attorneys for the Tesla shareholder argue that their work resulted in the “massive” benefit of returning shares to Tesla that otherwise would have gone to Musk and diluted the stock held by other Tesla investors. They value that benefit at $51.4 billion, using the difference between the stock price at the time of McCormick’s January ruling and the strike price of some 304 million stock options granted to Musk.
Attorney Greg Varallo told McCormick that he and his fellow plaintiff lawyers were simply asking for “a slice of the value pie we created.”
“We did battle with the very best,” Varallo added. “Litigation against Tesla is never easy. There are companies who play by the rules every day, and then there are companies like Tesla.”
The plaintiff attorneys argue that their fee request is “conservative” under Delaware law. Instead of a typical 33% fee recovery, they note that they are seeking only 11% of the shares now available to Tesla as the result of Musk’s options being rescinded by McCormick’s ruling. The judge agreed with the shareholder lawyers’ argument that Musk engineered the landmark 2018 pay package in sham negotiations with directors who were not independent.
Following the court ruling, Tesla shareholders met in June and ratified Musk’s 2018 pay package for a second time. McCormick made clear, however, that the June vote would not be considered in determining the request for attorney fees. It instead will be the subject of a separate hearing in early August.
Meanwhile, some opponents of the fee request argue that the plaintiff attorneys deserve no fee at all because they did not bestow any economic benefit on Tesla and instead may have even harmed the company. Opponents contend that the purported reversal of share dilution among Tesla stockholders is not a benefit to the Austin, Texas-based company itself and cannot be used to justify the fee request. They also note that the fee request fails to quantify or subtract potential negative consequences of the ruling, including the need to find a new way to compensate Musk for six years of non-salaried service to Tesla since 2018.
“The market did not react like this rescission remedy bestowed any benefit,” defense attorney John Reed told McCormick, noting that Tesla’s market capitalization dropped by $15 billion after her ruling.
Some critics argue that any fee award should be based only on the number of hours the plaintiff attorneys worked, and a reasonable hourly rate. Adding a multiplier to incentivize attorneys who work on a contingency basis in corporate disputes might also be appropriate, they have suggested. That approach could still result in a fee award of tens of millions of dollars. The current fee request equates to an hourly rate of about $288,000 for plaintiff attorneys and would result in an “unwholesome windfall,” according to opponents.
Acknowledging the criticism that the fee request has received, plaintiff attorneys in a recent court filing proposed an alternative fee structure. Under that scenario, they would be willing to accept $1.44 billion in cash, equating to an hourly fee of about $74,000.
veryGood! (9175)
Related
- All the Ways Megan Fox Hinted at Her Pregnancy With Machine Gun Kelly
- $6.5K reward as Arizona officials investigate the killing of a desert bighorn sheep near Gila Bend
- 'Percy Jackson' producers on Season 2, recasting Lance Reddick: 'We're in denial'
- It's happening! Taylor Swift arrives at Super Bowl 58 to support boyfriend Travis Kelce
- Channing Tatum Drops Shirtless Selfie After Zoë Kravitz Breakup
- Adele Defends Taylor Swift From Critical NFL Fans Ahead of Super Bowl
- Cher, Mariah Carey, Mary J. Blige top the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame 2024 nominee list
- 'Jeopardy!' boss really wants Emma Stone to keep trying to get on the show
- Wildfire map: Thousands of acres burn near New Jersey-New York border; 1 firefighter dead
- Wu-Tang Clan opens Las Vegas residency with vigor to spread 'hip-hop culture worldwide'
Ranking
- Pentagon secrets leaker Jack Teixeira set to be sentenced, could get up to 17 years in prison
- Haley tells Trump to ‘say it to my face’ after he questions her military husband’s whereabouts
- ‘Puppy Bowl’ celebrates a big anniversary this year, one that shelter and rescue pups will cheer
- NFL schedule today: Everything you need to know about Super Bowl 58
- FBI raids New York City apartment of Polymarket CEO Shayne Coplan, reports say
- Reba McEntire's soaring national anthem moves Super Bowl players to tears
- 'Lisa Frankenstein' struggles to electrify box office on a sleepy Super Bowl weekend
- Social isolation takes a toll on a rising number of South Korea's young adults
Recommendation
-
Why Game of Thrones' Maisie Williams May Be Rejoining the George R.R. Martin Universe
-
Alix Earle and Braxton Berrios Share Rare Insight into Their Relationship During Super Bowl Party Date
-
Chinese authorities cancel Argentina friendlies amid Messi backlash
-
How Las Vegas, once known as Sin City, became an unlikely sports haven
-
Golden Bachelorette: Joan Vassos Gets Engaged During Season Finale
-
Breaking down everything we know about Taylor Swift's album 'Tortured Poets Department'
-
NFL schedule today: Everything you need to know about Super Bowl 58
-
After labor victory, Dartmouth players return to the basketball court